The Herald Sun reported that 22 Victorian doctors have come out in opposition to same-sex marriage on the basis that “the evidence is clear that children who grow up in a family with a mother and father do better in all parameters than children without”.
The clear inference is that the opinion of these doctors that same-sex marriage is harmful to children, is based on medical research. Everyone is entitled to have their own opinion regarding same-sex marriage. For it is an issue that provokes strong responses on both sides of the debate. However, it is important that the opinions of Doctors for the Family be honestly represented as based on personal or religious views, and not medical science.
Dr Paula Gerber is an Associate Professor at the Monash University Law School and a Deputy Director of the Castan Centre for Human Rights Law.
Related news & commentary:
Crouch: Don’t believe the hype, kids with same-sex parents are well adjusted
Arnold: ‘Doctors for the Family’ see some Australians as more equal than others
Media release: Advocates encouraged by Hockey’s admission on same-sex parenting
Same-sex families hit back at doctors’ claims
Headspace blog: Doctors breaching their duty of care
3AW: Risk gay marriage would ‘increase homosexuality’, say Doctors for the Family
Factbox: Who are Doctors for the Family? (ABC News)
Victoria: Equal opportunity commissioner opposes same-sex marriage
Vagg: Ersatz science does not help inform debate about social policy
Castan Centre: ‘Doctors for the Family’ ill-informed on same-sex marriage
Rodney Croome: Love makes a family
Gay unions a ‘risk to kids’, say Doctors for the Family